The news that derails a little

Merckx says Pogacar is above him, Myriam looks for the article on rankings

Eddy Merckx says in the documentary “Anatomy of a G.O.A.T.”, about 45 minutes, on Eurosport 1 on Saturday and then on HBO Max, that Tadej Pogacar is now above him. Alberto Contador considers him the greatest of all time.

Myriam, a race commissioner, leafs through a binder at her kitchen table with a magnifying glass, looking for a rule article that doesn't exist.

Finding. Eddy Merckx, 81, said in a Eurosport documentary about Tadej Pogacar: “He is now above me.” The sentence is reported by HLN, the Flemish daily. I read it on Monday evening, the folder closed on the kitchen table, which is rare.

First. I note that the statement is not new. This summer, on VTM Nieuws, Merckx had already said that Pogacar was better than him, with less opposition than in his day, and more impressive in the mountains. The declarant maintains his position. That is consistent with him.

Second. I look for the article. The rulebook provides for a classification per race, a classification per stage, a classification by points. It does not provide for an all-time classification. There is no line, no time limit, no commissaire to hold it. I cannot homologate an event that has no finish.

Third. I list the figures I can verify. Pogacar, 28, won his fifth Tour de France this summer. Before him, Anquetil, Hinault, Indurain and Merckx. Five names, five victories each. On this precise point, they are tied. I write it in full.

Fourth. Alberto Contador states that he considers Pogacar the best of all time and cites Usain Bolt. Bolt does not fall under my discipline. I do not measure socks in athletics.

Tied, fine. But at what pressure, mind you?

Sandrine · the mechanic, fictional character

Verdict. The statement is admissible as a statement. It fits in no column.

What I do not note: that the declarant is also the party concerned, and that he placed himself below. I do not comment.

It’s true, we checked: HLN.

Did you enjoy this dispatch?

Get the dispatches by e-mail

The dispatches worth your time, by e-mail. No ads, unsubscribe in one click.

Also the mail from our other titles:

Our columnists’ reactions are fictional; the facts and real quotes are sourced above.

The other angles in French

The editor-in-chief chose this one: « B et D sont publiables, et B l'emporte d'un souffle : sa chute naît du fait lui-même, Merckx signant son propre déclassement. C invente un décor de côte qui change le témoignage de Thomas. »

RikThe Domestique

Merckx place Pogacar au-dessus de lui, Rik rappelle que derrière, personne ne l’a vu

Dans le documentaire « Anatomy of a G.O.A.T. », diffusé samedi à 13h50 sur Eurosport 1, Eddy Merckx, 81 ans, déclare que Tadej Pogacar est désormais au-dessus de lui. Le Slovène a remporté cet été son cinquième Tour de France.

  • Funniness 3/5
  • Faithfulness 4/5
  • Voice 3/5
  • Retweet 3/5
  • Good nature 4/5

The editor-in-chief’s comment « On se classe par ordre d'arrivée au café » fait sourire, mais « chez nous, en tête, on ne parlait pas » embrouille Rik, et la dernière phrase sur ce qu'« ils ne montreront pas » tire vers l'amertume.

Read this angle →

XavierThe Sunday Rider

Merckx place Pogacar au-dessus de lui, Xavier corrige son argument du sac

Eddy Merckx, 81 ans, déclare dans le documentaire « Anatomy of a G.O.A.T. », diffusé samedi dès 13h50 sur Eurosport 1, que Tadej Pogacar est désormais au-dessus de lui. Le Slovène, 28 ans, a gagné cet été son cinquième Tour de France.

  • Funniness 4/5
  • Faithfulness 5/5
  • Voice 5/5
  • Retweet 4/5
  • Good nature 5/5

The editor-in-chief’s comment Le zéro de la colonne qui bouge et l'argument du sac qui ne fait plus lever une tête au café : c'est drôle, incarné et fidèle, même si la mécanique du « déplace le zéro » demande une seconde lecture.

Read this angle →